Choice 评论

Goodman (Vanderbilt Univ.) reviews creation and evolution while favoring the Judeo-Christian understanding of how science and religion inform each other's agenda. He presents an argument for a mediating bridge between these two seemingly disparate understandings. Indicating that "Darwinism in biology and creation in religious thought are here to stay," Goodman works out a harmonious relationship between the two. In subsequent chapters, he surveys biblical creation followed by evolution. Then he outlines three lines for critiquing Darwin, as represented by theorists Adam Sedgwick, Karl Popper, and Alvin Plantinga. Indicative of Goodman's position is one of his concluding sentiments: "The emergence of purpose and subjecthood make evolution itself a powerful argument for creation." This key quotation orients the work well. In the context of the four possible conclusions regarding the evolution versus creation debate--conflict, independence, dialogue, or integration--Goodman clearly identifies himself within the latter category. The author posits a natural theology while arguing that creation and evolution are not antagonistic views of life but ones that may complement one another. This work would be employed best as an introductory volume about the topic and is most appropriate for neophytes in the field. Summing Up: Recommended. Lower- and upper-level undergraduates; general readers. G. M. Smith Delaware County Community College