Choice 评论
In her preface, Backscheider (Auburn Univ.) makes high claims for this collection as the fruit of several lifetimes' feminist rereading of 18th-century fiction. These claims turn out to be justified by a truly extraordinary book. Revising Women brings together five long literary-historical essays, all of the highest merit: Betty Rizzo traces the uses of Gothic plots and motifs by women (and homosexual male) writers of the period; Mitzi Meyers outlines a completely new reading of Maria Edgeworth, based in a new understanding of Edgeworth's relations to the powerful men in her family; and in an essay titled "Jane Austen and the Culture of Circulating Libraries: The Construction of Female Literacy," Barbara Benedict reexamines reading practices in light of contemporary notions of taste, display, and "the feminization of discriminating choice." Perhaps best of all are Backscheider's own contributions: a long introductory overview of 18th-century women's fiction and "The Rise of Gender as a Political Category," arguably the best single essay yet written on Samuel Richardson's novel Clarissa. Collections of this sort are often uneven or thin, or repeat work already done; this one is so uniformly fresh, exciting, and useful that it deserves a place in all academic collections serving upper-division undergraduates and above. D. L. Patey; Smith College