《学校图书馆杂志》(School Library Journal)书评
Gr 3-5-- Kent briefly summarizes the life of the great Apache leader. Emphasis is on the presentation of the known facts, with little analysis of those facts. While he uses pejorative adjectives (savage, hate-filled, creeping) routinely, Kent also takes care to point out that the Apaches and other tribes were not treated fairly or honestly, and that whites were often unreasonably hostile and violent. The events of Geronimo's life are dramatic enough to sweep readers along despite the somewhat dry recounting. The numerous photographs will also spark interest, and are a vast improvement over the dull drawings that used to appear in this series. Ronald Syme's Geronimo (Morrow, 1975; o.p.) is equally accessible for this age group, but lacks the striking photographs. Wright's straightforward account of ``the Wall'' that honors America's Vietnam War dead covers the genesis of the idea, the design contest, the c ongressional action that made it possible, the construction, the controversy, and the opening of this compelling memorial structure. The photographs, many in color, add dramatic impact to the low-keyed presentation. Brent Ashabranner's Always to Remember (Dodd, 1988) contains much more information, but is for an older audience. Both titles should prove appealing to browsers and useful for reports. --Elaine Fort Weischedel, Turner Free Library, Randolph, MA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
《书目》(Booklist)书评
Gr. 3-5. This introduction to the legendary Apache warrior makes clear the cultural clashes that resulted when Mexican and American settlers began making inroads on lands the Apaches called home. Relying on excerpts from Geronimo's writings (none of which are identified), Kent describes the warrior's early life and tells how as a young man he lost his wife and three children in a raid by Mexican soldiers, which seemingly triggered his transformation into a particularly fierce leader. Kent acknowl~edges the brutality on both sides as he describes Geronimo's success in evading capture by U.S. troops. His eventual celebrity status after he and his band finally were conquered is also covered. Illustrated with many contemporary photo~graphs, some reprinted in sepia tones. --Denise Wilms
